Milksour

January 28, 2005

So… last night I went to CVS to pick up some of Jen’s pain meds and a few things for sweet baby Hayes. On the list: formula, baby wipes, Purel(tm) and colace. Good times. Of course, in classic Eric fashion, I forgot one of them, the Purel, and to compound things, the CVS in my neighborhood doesn’t carry Oxycodon.

As a result, I had to walk over to the other CVS in the Back Bay. (Oh, BTW, as I am writing this, my wife has informed me, “We have tohave another child”) Not too far away, but in my huge Sorrels in 3 feet of snow some of which is half-assedly plowed and with just bringing the little dude home, it wasn’t close either. More fun.

Then last night happened… and this morning… WTF wasn’t Hayes sleeping and WTF was he eating so much? Moreover, was this type of behavior normal? We decided this might be because I bought a formula that wasn’t exactly the same as the one in the hospital. So, this morning, on four hours of sleep and without caffine I trudged over to the CVS 3 blocks away (the close one) to buy the Purel and the correct formula issue.

The first person I see appears to be the manager. She’s in the soap isle.

“Do you carry Purel,” I asked her. “I bet I’m standing right in front of it.”

She walks over and points behind me.

“It’s right there,” says she, kindly. And then, in my defense, “We’ve got lots of soaps.”

“I guess you do, but I’m not sure I’d find it if it were the only thing here. I’ve only had 4 hours of sleep.”

I like to tell strangers about my woes in the hopes of eliciting their sympathy. But then, you know that, you’re reading my blog.

“And speaking of 4 hours of sleep, do you have the key to the formula?”

A weird sentence, I know, but they keep the formula locked up so that it doesn’t get the 5 finger discount. I tell her of my plight and that my son keeps on eating. She tells me that her daughter was the same way, which made me feel better.

Why am I telling you this? Well, I like stories. I also thought I had a punchline, because Jen thought it was funny. Now, well… yah. I wrote it and I ain’t erasing.

Anyway, we were concerned with the massive amount of formula the little guy was enhaling each feeding so first thing this morning we made a nooner appointment with our pediatrician. We got Dr. Judit, instead, a new doctor who was fabulous. We told he of our grand plan: we would embrace the bottle, as there is still no milk from the mommy, and carry on. As one nurse at the hospital told Jen before we left, “If you do breastfeed, he’ll be feeding 24 hours.” Not too far from the truth, I’m sure.

There. I said it. It’s beyond milksour.

This was a HARD choice that we didn’t take lightly. We TRIED so hard. Frankly, we feel like we’ve failed our child in some way. It sucks. And that’s the last time I’ll use that pun. During one of Jen’s crying spells about it last night… actually while Jen and Hayes were crying a duet, I had visions of a headline: “Man Opens Fire on La Leche League with Breast Pump, 4 Injured.” It got that bad.

Jen spoke with some of her friends that seconded our assesment. We’ve done much discussing and it’s the right thing to do for our family. We’ve got good benchmarks for bottlefed normalcy, Jen and her sister were both bottlefed, and both did better on their SATs then George W (1206– 566 verbal, 640 math). Jen’s sister even became a doctor by way of Cornell, Harvard and Michigan, all of which I am told are pretty decent schools. So, what the hell, we didn’t get into parenting thinking that we could do everything right.

4 Comments »

  • tulip says:


    You guys are doing the est thing for your family and don’t let anyone tell you differently. A happy well fed baby is the goal and you do what you can. Hugs to Jen because I know this was a tough one but you are doing great momma!

  • Jennifer says:


    I feel as if I must comment on this. I tried for seven weeks to feed my child from the breast. Come to find out that I just didn’t produce enough milk. I cried all the time, pumped day and night just to get four ounces of milk and did every trick in the book to help produce more. My husband and I were disapointed but after many weeks decided to to formula only. It was the best thing I could have done. Now I don’t have to weep when I feed her, or stress about a non existant milk supply. I enjoy the feedings. It’s months later now (she is nine months old) and I still think it was the best thing I could do. All we can do is our best…and sometimes it doesn’t work out the way we plan all the time. Your child will grow up just fine without the boob milk. Mine is doing well to!

  • More Diapers. Eric Sagalyn’s quest for modern fatherhood. » For Just 2 Cups of Coffee a Day… says:


    […] solved HBomb’s explosions. Yup, it’s the formula, stupid. When we first made the tough decision to go to formula we decided upon the same formula Hayes had been enjoying in the hospita […]

  • Stephanie A. says:


    I know this post is over a year old, but I wish that I had found it sooner. My son is now 4 months old and we’re over the whole breastfeeding speedbump and now use fomrula. However, it was such a horrible experience for us. The fact that I barely had any milk (the most I ever got at one time was 1 oz- both breasts) was bad enough, but then the judgement that came from others, including La Leche League, just diminished my confidence at motherhood.

    I love your headline comment, as my husband was just as bitter about LLL, too!

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a comment